Home Risen Risen2 Risen3 Forum English Russian

Registrieren Hilfe Kalender Heutige Beiträge

Umfrageergebnis anzeigen: Which copy protection method would you tolerate as buying customer?

  • Simple DVD check

    30 52,63%
  • SecuROM (without DRM)

    14 24,56%
  • Tagès

    3 5,26%
  • Starforce

    3 5,26%
  • SafeDisc

    6 10,53%
  • ProtectCD, WTM, others

    3 5,26%
  • Serial number (no online verification)

    32 56,14%
  • DRM without installation limit

    10 17,54%
  • DRM with installation limit

    3 5,26%
  • Handbook questions, code wheels, etc.

    15 26,32%
  • None at all

    15 26,32%
Multiple-Choice-Umfrage.  
Teilnehmer
57. Du darfst bei dieser Umfrage nicht abstimmen
Seite 1 von 6 12345 ... Letzte »
Ergebnis 1 bis 20 von 111
  1. #1 Zitieren
    Deus Avatar von Maladiq
    Registriert seit
    May 2008
    Ort
    WoP Servers
    Beiträge
    11.229
    Zitat Zitat von doberlec Beitrag anzeigen
    As for the pirates, I'm in a situation similar to a greek tragedy. Going with online activation is the only secure move right now but it will also upset the loyal customers. If we go the other direction we will get praise from the fans, but we're easy bait for the pirates and most of the kids out there don't give a flying f&%$ if they are destroying a business or not. What do they care if everything goes down the tubes when they can boast to their peers in school, right?
    Looks like the guys from DS want to go with DRM. I have made this petition against that here:

    http://www.petitiononline.com/risendrm/petition.html

    Please sign it if you are against the use of DRM for Risen.

    I add the folowing links to show you why drm is bad and not worth it:


    More about DRM here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_rights_management
    Myths about DRM, why it is bad: http://geocities.com/foobar_77/drm-myths.html
    Some thoughts about copy protection: http://geocities.com/foobar_77/thoughts-on-cp.html

    Thanks foobar

    Anyways, guys, spread the news, and please vote it. It is a protest not only against drm for risen, but also against drm in general. And Risen being special for us, it counts more, so don;t let it be ruined by this kind of things.
    Maladiq ist offline

  2. #2 Zitieren
    Deep Silver a. D. Avatar von doberlec
    Registriert seit
    Mar 2006
    Beiträge
    1.897
    Zitat Zitat von Maladiq
    Anyways, guys, spread the news, and please vote it. It is a protest not only against drm for risen, but also against drm in general. And Risen being special for us, it counts more, so don;t let it be ruined by this kind of things.
    I'm sorry but you shouldn't lead people into the thought that Risen will have DRM because the topic isn't even settled. Unless of course you're not really interested in a good discussion and just up for some publicity stunt and after asking for some attention.
    doberlec ist offline

  3. #3 Zitieren
    Knight
    Registriert seit
    Jun 2007
    Beiträge
    1.691
    yeah i do too think it's a bit early for something like that. instead of panicing, lets rether have a discussion about it? I mean, i already said, if there will be limitation in using the game meaning that there is possibility that i won't be able to play game that i payed for for some period of time, i ain't buying it. But nothing is for sure right now, so lets try to have argumented discussion instead.

    Especially as publishers don't really like to openly debate about these things with fans.
    Zocky ist offline

  4. #4 Zitieren
    Deep Silver a. D. Avatar von doberlec
    Registriert seit
    Mar 2006
    Beiträge
    1.897
    Zitat Zitat von Zocky Beitrag anzeigen
    Especially as publishers don't really like to openly debate about these things with fans.
    Actually I do prefer an open debate about that, this is why I have started the discussion with that to begin with. But once you reach into the realms of petitions it's even hard to know if the people signing there even know what Risen is.
    doberlec ist offline

  5. #5 Zitieren
    Deus Avatar von Maladiq
    Registriert seit
    May 2008
    Ort
    WoP Servers
    Beiträge
    11.229
    Zitat Zitat von doberlec Beitrag anzeigen
    Actually I do prefer an open debate about that, this is why I have started the discussion with that to begin with. But once you reach into the realms of petitions it's even hard to know if the people signing there even know what Risen is.
    Who would sign smth just for the sake of it? I would consider this petition as a poll, to see how much people in general are caring about something like this. As I said in the first post, you are considering it, I know it hasn;t been settled. Well, if you would take the decission to use this method, then trying to do something would be too late, wouldn't it? This way we can see how the potential buyers are feeling about this method and you can base your later decission on the results. Fair enough?
    Maladiq ist offline

  6. #6 Zitieren
    Deep Silver a. D. Avatar von doberlec
    Registriert seit
    Mar 2006
    Beiträge
    1.897
    Since when is a petition against something a start for a good discussion? You haven't explained them anything, you're just asking for their opinion although they have no clue how such a protection would work. Should I start a petition which says: "Do you want that Piranha Bytes does another game after Risen?" That would be the same idiotic move, eh?

    Actually the reaction of you guys is telling me more about the discussion than the discussion itself. And that drives me to my conclusion that there is no way to talk with you in a meaningfull way because everytime there only a hint that someone in the universe is thinking about something is setting of an alarm bell in your head.
    doberlec ist offline

  7. #7 Zitieren
    Cat  Avatar von Larisa
    Registriert seit
    Oct 2006
    Beiträge
    8.520
    Zitat Zitat von doberlec Beitrag anzeigen
    And that drives me to my conclusion that there is no way to talk with you in a meaningfull way
    Imho, you take it too hard. It's to be expected to find radical behavior in game related forums, don't you think?
    Larisa ist offline

  8. #8 Zitieren
    Deus Avatar von Maladiq
    Registriert seit
    May 2008
    Ort
    WoP Servers
    Beiträge
    11.229
    Zitat Zitat von doberlec Beitrag anzeigen
    Since when is a petition against something a start for a good discussion? You haven't explained them anything, you're just asking for their opinion although they have no clue how such a protection would work. Should I start a petition which says: "Do you want that Piranha Bytes does another game after Risen?" That would be the same idiotic move, eh?

    Actually the reaction of you guys is telling me more about the discussion than the discussion itself. And that drives me to my conclusion that there is no way to talk with you in a meaningfull way because everytime there only a hint that someone in the universe is thinking about something is setting of an alarm bell in your head.
    Dober, you disapoint me
    Maladiq ist offline

  9. #9 Zitieren
    Knight
    Registriert seit
    Jun 2007
    Beiträge
    1.691
    well i do think all of you, doberlec included, are overreacting.

    Doberlec, this kind of limitation in games usually has reactions like this. I do agree we should talk more about it (with arguments), but you must understand also us, fans, that this is one system we all hate enough to not buy game if necesary. We can talk about it, but to be honest, i'm not sure if there's much to be talked about. It's clear you would really like to have this limitation thingy, while it's also sure we all hate that thing, and i don't think there is middle ground here. Risen either will have limitation system, or not. So if we proceed, it's gonna be either us trying to convince you how bad this is, or you trying to convince us how good it is, but both cases will fail, as we all stand strongly with our beliefs on this subject.
    Zocky ist offline

  10. #10 Zitieren
    Deep Silver a. D. Avatar von doberlec
    Registriert seit
    Mar 2006
    Beiträge
    1.897
    Zitat Zitat von mistress_larisa Beitrag anzeigen
    Imho, you take it too hard. It's to be expected to find radical behavior in game related forums, don't you think?
    No but I'm after a solution to a big problem. And we are not going to get to a solution by thinking black or white. I'm feeling reminded of the sentence "Are you with us or against us" which coined the Bush aera in the US (which brought us all into deep shit the last years) and the outcome is that everyone is NOT in the least interested to budge one millimeter from his or her position. Not even when the stakes are high and the aim is important.

    Now let me define our aim: I need to find a way that our game doesn't get pirated on day 1 and on the first weeks. Is DRM doing the trick? Maybe, but only if it is accepted by the buyers and that in my opinion depends on some variables. Because there is a service called Steam which is in fact selling games and is very successfull. So there is a way to acceptance.
    doberlec ist offline

  11. #11 Zitieren
    Knight Avatar von vivaxardas
    Registriert seit
    Apr 2008
    Ort
    Tir Nan Og
    Beiträge
    1.619
    Zitat Zitat von doberlec Beitrag anzeigen
    But once you reach into the realms of petitions it's even hard to know if the people signing there even know what Risen is.
    So cynical, but so true...
    Petitions may serve as a bad publicity for a game. I do not know guys how for you, but for me these petitions on fan sites indicate that it is likely that there is something wrong with the game, and that I should steer clear from it. I want Risen to succeed, and I would not want to scare off some casual gamers.
    Also why not to leave it in the hands of the publisher? If the publisher makes a bad choice, he looses much more then we do. It is a publisher who is more concerned with making a right choice. So let him decide what to do. The publisher has enough professinals to do it, while our perspective may be kinda limited.
    SKEPTICISM IS A VIRTUE!

    Лидия: Любимый, я беременна!
    Я: ФУС-РО-ДА!!!!
    vivaxardas ist offline

  12. #12 Zitieren
    Deus Avatar von Maladiq
    Registriert seit
    May 2008
    Ort
    WoP Servers
    Beiträge
    11.229
    Zitat Zitat von doberlec Beitrag anzeigen
    Because there is a service called Steam which is in fact selling games and is very successfull.
    Have you paid attention lately to steam? It has begun to have a lot of critics since the prices are as high as the ones of distributed via stores games, or even higher. We all hoped that Steam would bring the era of the 3rd or 4th party to an end (that meaning publishers or retailers) to an end, thus sttudios having more freedom, the distribution could take place easier and the prices would go down. But if you (and i reffer to you as the representant of DS) take the example of that huge rip-off called Steam, that sais a lot.
    Maladiq ist offline

  13. #13 Zitieren
    Deep Silver a. D. Avatar von doberlec
    Registriert seit
    Mar 2006
    Beiträge
    1.897
    Zitat Zitat von Maladiq Beitrag anzeigen
    Dober, you disapoint me
    You're not realizing that you're driving me out of this forum with such actions do you?

    Zitat Zitat von Zocky
    It's clear you would really like to have this limitation thingy, while it's also sure we all hate that thing, and i don't think there is middle ground here.
    No. You are not thinking out of the box, because I asked in the other thread how many activations would suffice. If you tell me that its not working this way, we will find another way. THink of it as a white paper, and the rules are not written.

    Zitat Zitat von vivaxardas
    The publisher has enough professinals to do it, while our perspective may be kinda limited.
    True but we only see our perspective.

    EDIT: Will carry on the discussion in the original thread...
    doberlec ist offline

  14. #14 Zitieren
    Cat  Avatar von Larisa
    Registriert seit
    Oct 2006
    Beiträge
    8.520
    Zitat Zitat von vivaxardas Beitrag anzeigen
    I do not know guys how for you, but for me these petitions on fan sites indicate that it is likely that there is something wrong with the game, and that I should steer clear from it.
    For me also a petition sounds negative. It's usually when people demand something from a higher authority and they are not listened.
    Larisa ist offline

  15. #15 Zitieren
    Knight Avatar von RobinHood 13.
    Registriert seit
    Apr 2008
    Beiträge
    1.836
    Empire total war has some seriously annoying protection systems, and at those times I don't have internet it will be those games I would play, but apparently that's not possible.
    Same applies for risen.
    Empire total war took also loooong time to install because of all the actication bullshit, and if I can compare it with anything, it would have to be installing sims 2 with all it's expansions. A real time consuming process. I don't want to do alot of work just to be able to install a game.
    The promise of the protection might be removed in a patch is not good enough at all. The install limitation thingy would seriously harm my possibilites of buying the game, and my opinion of deepsilver as a name.
    Please keep to the regular insert cd protection (only make it work this time, unlike G2 which had some problems on especially newer computers). Many people care about what they put on their machine, and games that include programs that use surveilance to check if we use a legal version is kinda like hacking.
    Protection systems may harm sales, SPORE. While others say they increase sales. For Empire Total War I dont know, but I bought the game, a bit much to pay for a new game nowadays, but I had tried it and it was very good. My overall experience fell drastically when I tried to install it, and I got to know that theyve put quite some annoying protection systems. They managed to lure the money out of me, but what happens when they create a new game. I will definitely check out what kinda protection systems they use then, and hear what others say about it first.

    Here's an honest opinion of will I buy the game or not.
    Most likely I will buy the game (even with an annoying protection system), but that's because it's PB and the game seems to correct the errors from G3.
    With protection systems I might still buy the game, but deepsilver will go from a (+) to a (-) in my book and also harm future releases. I will also most likely wait to hear others opinions of it though, and maybe even wait til price has dropped.
    If I hear bad reviews, buggy or another G3 failure I will also wait to check out if they'll fix it.

    Other advices.
    Release a good demo before release that gives the gamer a taste of what the game is like. Many use illegal downloads as a demo trial, only problem is their then less likely to buy the game.
    Have something materialistic which you don't get by downloading and put this in regular version (not only collectors edition). That won't cost you very much but give gamers a reason to buy the game. The internet download version should then be cheaper than the buy in games store version.

    I hope if Deepsilver have any plans of a protection systems, they'll redecide and stick to the old, insert correct cd.
    RobinHood 13. ist offline

  16. #16 Zitieren
    Deep Silver a. D. Avatar von doberlec
    Registriert seit
    Mar 2006
    Beiträge
    1.897
    Zitat Zitat von RobinHood 13. Beitrag anzeigen
    Other advices.
    Release a good demo before release that gives the gamer a taste of what the game is like. Many use illegal downloads as a demo trial, only problem is their then less likely to buy the game.
    Have something materialistic which you don't get by downloading and put this in regular version (not only collectors edition). That won't cost you very much but give gamers a reason to buy the game. The internet download version should then be cheaper than the buy in games store version.
    These things are planned

    Zitat Zitat von RobinHood 13. Beitrag anzeigen
    I hope if Deepsilver have any plans of a protection systems, they'll redecide and stick to the old, insert correct cd.
    No need to redecide when no final decision is taken. But it seems that the petition thread already made its way into the brains of the people - funny how fast manipulation works.
    doberlec ist offline

  17. #17 Zitieren
    Waldläufer Avatar von Pericle
    Registriert seit
    Jan 2006
    Beiträge
    116
    I say it was a great idea to start a petition, so that PB and the publisher will know the consequences of choosing to use DRM for Risen.

    Before you actually make up your mind, you will have this to think about.

    I have only one thing to say, if the game is good, it will sell, if not, don't blame the pirates that is just silly, even pirates buy games that they love... keep that in mind.
    Pericle ist offline

  18. #18 Zitieren
    Rookie
    Registriert seit
    Apr 2009
    Beiträge
    5
    Hello all.

    Thank you Doberlec for participating in this discussion. It's good to see a publisher engaging in dialog with the customer base. Such is a virtue I see very rarely out side of the independent sphere, and I think as a practice that if continued, will only strengthen your company as time goes on. This helps me as a customer respect Deep Silver and will ensure that when I see your logo on more products I will remember that you have communicated positively with the community and take into account our opinions. I am pleased to see these business practices and I hope you continue.

    Please do not make the mistake of being "driven out" of a discussion such as this. The fans here do not mean any harm to you personally or to your company. For many customers this is a very sensitive subject so it is inevitable that there will be emotions abound. To shut the door and walk away from talking over the issue because some people may get defensive/argumentative/hostile, only makes people loose respect for your company, which does not equal increased sales. Staying involved until a solution that makes everyone happy is obtained will impress people, and impressed people means more sales.

    Anyways, on to my points:

    In my opinion DRM is counter productive, you can slap as much of it on a product as you like and there will always be a way to circumvent it. Leaving the pirate untouched because the DRM is removed, while the legitimate customer gets to bear the burden. Taking Steam for instance, it didn't save Empire: Total war from having a day one pirate copy out on torrents, which in turn made it easier for the user to play without needing Steam running in the background (which for one reason or another there seems to be many individuals out there who cannot stand a middleman of any sort).

    In this day and age, peer-to-peer distribution is a fact of life, and as time goes on more and more of the population will share more and more information. Heck, you have Ray Kurzwiel out there talking about how in a decade or two people will be emailing each other their favorite toaster/computer/car designs, from which people will have their nanobots build for them (Could you envision the uproar from customers if their new legitimate BMW wouldn't let them drive to work one day because it incorrectly identified itself as a pirate version? Or what if they just randomly shut off while in use? What if after every 3-5 oil changes/tune-ups/hardware modifications, the car would cease to run, and you would have to call both BMW and the Auto Rights Management company to reset it for you. What if in the illegitimate BMW you didn't have to worry about if it was going to run when you want it to?). If there's something out there that's popular it will be shared, just like how people pass out reefers these days. Therefor the only absolute way to not have your product pirated is to not make it at all, however you can't pay the bills that way.

    Something I find amusing is that "no DRM" is now used to market games. Independent companies are taking pieces (and sometimes chucks) of the market, selling games with no more protection than a serial key. Look at Stardock pulling in a 10+ to 1 profit on some of it's unprotected titles and their games are pirated just as much as every other popular series is. Apparently not releasing the product until it's complete, fully supporting your products with patches until all bugs are squashed, releasing plenty of free add-ons in between expansions or sequels, deep interaction with the community, and supporting modding efforts seems to catch peoples respect and makes them want to support the company. Who would have thought? It wouldn't be very hard to show other examples of this trend working.

    In conclusion, I think the best direction for Deep Silver to go, if it decides to combat "profit loss" due to the piracy of Risen, would be to give those pirates honest reasons to purchase the product than focusing on proven futile attempts to punish them or lock them out of the game. Just because they've pirated the game does not mean they are not still a potential customer. For Instance, lets say a torrent springs up on thepiratebay, Deep Silver could make a comment "Hey guys, I'm so and so from Deep Silver, Publisher of Risen. We hope you appreciate all the hard work PB has done! If you enjoy Risen, we would be grateful if you purchased a copy here at *online retailer* to help us develop more games like this for you. Also, if you have any questions or comments please do not hesitate to join our forum here at *Official Risen forum*! Looking forward to hear from you! Thanks alot, so and so!". Not only would that impress those who read it, the act alone could generate word of mouth advertisements. "Holy Sh*t, that publisher actually seems human! ...And all this time I thought all publishers were just money hoarding spawns of hell that treated customers like cattle! I think it won't kill me to support their title then!" etc. I'm sure there are tons of ways Deep Silver can reach across the aisle like this that would truly benefit everyone and develop some admiration for the company as well.

    Thank you, I hope this helps.
    Puppyonastik ist offline

  19. #19 Zitieren
    Knight Commander Avatar von Demonium
    Registriert seit
    Oct 2006
    Ort
    HELLAS
    Beiträge
    2.422
    I can say that its annoying when you need an Internet connection to do the activation for example...What people with ought any Internet connection should do?

    The main target for the publisher is that the copy protection will hold for a week until it will be cracked. Because its 100% sure that it will be cracked one day or another.

    To say the truth even if i have a game original, i will use a crack to play it with ought a DVD.

    The reasons: Annoying...every time you need to play you have to insert it into the DVD rom.
    And most important. Scratches...I have the impression that the DVDs are of very poor quality. I am VERY careful, i never drop them on the floor or on sharp surfaces and into a month they are full of scratches. I almost destroyed my Rome Total War CD...I uninstalled it and i couldnt install it later because it was full of scratches...

    Ever thought to sell the games into a USB flash drive instead of DVDs?
    Demonium ist offline

  20. #20 Zitieren
    Knight Commander Avatar von Bamfy
    Registriert seit
    Jul 2007
    Ort
    Pripyat City
    Beiträge
    2.446
    As long as there won't be any instalation limit(Spore) or won't be able to play it because of DRM(Clear Sky),I don't have nothing against.

    In this case,most people know Risen from internet,not from tv or radio so if there will be an internet check(or how you guys call it),I don't see what's the problem.I wouldn't care if I lose 5 minutes to be able to play Risen,I wouldn't care.

    Although I do hope you don't use Starforce or Tages,since they have a bad reputation with adding some bugs,even problems with installing the game even if you have the original cd.

    In any case,Deep Silver is the only one who decides what they will do,so don't really see the point of the petition.
    Oh,and I won't be dissapointed if DS will use DRM (Tages).After all,they have a life too.
    Bamfy ist offline

Seite 1 von 6 12345 ... Letzte »

Berechtigungen

  • Neue Themen erstellen: Nein
  • Themen beantworten: Nein
  • Anhänge hochladen: Nein
  • Beiträge bearbeiten: Nein
  •